Eleven members of the Class of 2018 committed to playing athletics at the college level, representing eight different sports: baseball, basketball, crew, football, ice hockey, lacrosse, soccer and swimming.

• Sasha Arefyev, Swimming, Dickinson College (NCAA Division III)
• Michael DeGregorio, Crew, University of Pittsburgh (Club)
• Riley DiFiore, Lacrosse, York College (NCAA Division III)
• Frankie Fuhrer, Basketball, Case Western Reserve University (NCAA Division III)
• Lindsey Grune, Swimming, Emory University (NCAA Division III) - not pictured
• Tyler Hackaday, Football, Marietta College (NCAA Division III)
• Becca Huss, Ice Hockey, Hobart and William Smith Colleges (NCAA Division III)
• Benjamin Kosbie, Baseball, Allegheny College (NCAA Division III)
• Leila Skinner, Crew, Tufts University (NCAA Division III)
• Spencer Smith, Ice Hockey, Babson College (NCAA Division III)
• Hannah Steffey, Soccer, Lake Forest College (NCAA Division III) - not pictured

Twenty-two members of the Shady Side Academy Class of 2017 committed to playing collegiate athletics at the NCAA level. The group included nine student-athletes who committed to play at NCAA Division I institutions and 13 at NCAA Division III. The students represent 12 different sports: baseball, crew, cross country, field hockey, football, golf, ice hockey, lacrosse, soccer, swimming, tennis and track & field.

• Ashley Azzarello - Swimming, University of Pittsburgh (Division I)
• Caroline Benec - Field Hockey, University of Rochester (Division III)
• Brendan Brazinski - Soccer, University of Rochester (Division III)
• Eliza Cochran - Soccer, Georgetown University (Division I)
• Alexa Conomikes - Field Hockey, Columbia University (Division I)
• Knox Coulter - Golf, Tufts University (Division III)
• Olivia Coyne - Ice Hockey, Trine University (Division III)
• Mac Ference - Lacrosse, Rhodes College (Division III)
• Nathan Genstein - Football, Washington University in St. Louis (Division III)
• Devin Gramley - Tennis, Denison University (Division III)
• Elizabeth Harper - Soccer, United States Military Academy (Division I)
• Patrick Hill-Junke - Soccer, University of Rochester (Division III)
• Caldwell Holden - Cross Country, Bennington College (Division III)
• Katie James - Golf, Southern Methodist University (Division I)
• Julia Johnson - Crew, University of Wisconsin (Division I)
• Clayton Krol - Lacrosse, High Point University (Division I)
• Gannon Leech - Cross Country and Track & Field, Bowdoin College (Division III)
• Kendra McBroom - Lacrosse, Chatham University (Division III)
• Casey Morrow - Golf, Bucknell University (Division I)
• Colby Poerio - Field Hockey, Hobart & William Smith Colleges (Division III)
• Nicholas Tarasi - Baseball, Allegheny College (Division III)
• Christopher Woodings - Lacrosse, Washington & Lee University (Division III)

Twenty-four members of the Shady Side Academy Class of 2016 committed to playing collegiate athletics at the NCAA level. The group included nine student-athletes who committed to play at NCAA Division I institutions, one at NCAA Division II, and 14 at NCAA Division III. The students represent 13 different sports: baseball, basketball, crew, cross country, football, golf, ice hockey, lacrosse, soccer, softball, swimming, tennis and track & field.

• Joseph "Trip" Calihan - Football, Washington & Lee University (Division I)
• Killian Cavanaugh - Baseball, University of Chicago (Division III)
• Connor Colombo - Cross Country and Track & Field, Case Western Reserve University
• Caroline Colville - Swimming, Denison University (Division III)
• Jordan Conn - Football, Davidson College (Division I FCS)
• Ananya Dua - Tennis, Cornell University (Division 1)
• Erin Frohlich – Basketball and Softball, Grove City College (Division III)
• Wyatt Glover - Ice Hockey, Williams College (Division III)
• Blake Goodman - Lacrosse, University of Richmond (Division I)
• Tyler Gorse - Baseball, Mount Union College (Division III)
• Eric Harris - Football, Franklin & Marshall College (Division III)
• Max Jaffe - Lacrosse, Ohio Wesleyan University (Division III)
• Jack Katarincic - Golf, College of the Holy Cross (Division I)
• Courtney Kozdron – Softball, Oberlin College (Division III)
• Peyton Lane - Lacrosse, Amherst College (Division III)
• John McDonagh - Ice Hockey, Assumption College (Division II)
• Lindsey Miller – Tennis, Duquesne University (Division I)
• Samantha Morlacci – Soccer, Penn State University-Behrend (Division III)
• Emma Perelman - Tennis, Emory University (Division III)
• Matt Rytel - Soccer, Lafayette College (Division I)
• Sarah Scheid - Crew, University of Pennsylvania (Division I)
• Donald "Doc" Szlachetka - Lacrosse, U.S. Air Force Academy (Division I)
• Alayna Trice - Ice Hockey, Hamilton College (Division III)
• Mike Ware - Football, Fordham University (Division I FCS)

Seventeen members of the Shady Side Academy Class of 2015 committed to playing collegiate athletics at the NCAA level. The group includes four student-athletes who committed to play for NCAA Division I institutions and 13 who committed to NCAA Division III schools. The students represented six different sports: baseball, football, ice hockey, lacrosse, soccer and softball.

• Rachel Khalouf - girls' ice hockey, University of Vermont, NCAA Division I
• Charlotte Redican - girls' lacrosse, Colgate University, NCAA Division I
• Robby Woodings - boys' lacrosse, U.S. Military Academy (Army), NCAA Division I
• Louis Berry IV - football, Mount Union College, NCAA Division III
• Skyler Blaxter - football, Kenyon College, NCAA Division III
• Jackie Cepicka - girls' soccer, Washington and Jefferson College, NCAA Division III
• Alex Fazioli - football, Kenyon College, NCAA Division III
• Alex Hartz - baseball, St. Vincent College, NCAA Division III
• Gab Harchelroad - girls' lacrosse, U.S. Naval Academy, NCAA Division I
• Calsey Holshue - girls soccer, St. Vincent College, NCAA Division III
• Connor Jones - boys' lacrosse, Connecticut College, NCAA Division III
• Patrick Loughran - football, Williams College, NCAA Division III
• Kara Pooley - girls' lacrosse, Hamilton College, NCAA Division III
• Andrea Rockey - girls' ice hockey, Hamilton College, NCAA Division III
• Chris Santucci - baseball, Kenyon College, NCAA Division III
• Olivia Stokes - girls' ice hockey, Williams College, NCAA Division III
• Jackie Yencik - softball, University of Rochester, NCAA Division III

Nine members of the Shady Side Academy Class of 2014 committed to playing collegiate athletics at the NCAA level. Seven student-athletes signed National Letters of Intent to play at NCAA Division I and II institutions, while two committed to playing at NCAA Division III non-scholarship institutions.

• Jarred Brevard - Fordham University Football - NCAA Division I-FCS
• Dennis Briggs - University of Pittsburgh Football - NCAA Division I-FBS
• Tucker Gillman – Georgetown University Lacrosse - NCAA Division I
• Max Prizant - Bucknell University Track & Field – NCAA Division I
• Chuckie Scales - Bucknell University Baseball - NCAA Division I
• Maggie Scott - Miami University (Ohio) Soccer - NCAA Division I
• Tyrel Hill - Notre Dame College (Ohio) Football - NCAA Division II
• Charles Calabrese - Tufts University Football - NCAA Division III
• Mike Concordia - Bates College Lacrosse - NCAA Division III